Abstract

The association of leadership with males and masculinity has resulted in women’s underrepresentation in top leadership positions. Leadership research and literature historically overlooked gender, and recent efforts to include women often rely on masculine-centric models. Research indicates gender stereotypes and biases, role congruity, and the glass cliff contribute to the vast gender disparity at the highest levels. However, these explanations fail to address a root cause: the need to embrace feminine attributes as valuable in leadership. The purpose of this qualitative study was to identify feminine attributes that enabled successful women leaders to lead effectively, thereby providing new insights into leadership research and challenging traditional leadership norms. The study sought to develop a leadership framework for implementation in secondary education (grades 6-12) that promotes a more inclusive and equitable understanding of leadership and fosters leadership development among young women. This study employed a constructivist grounded theory methodology utilizing an integrated theoretical approach combining feminist theory and effective leadership frameworks. Fourteen women leaders aged 34 to 77 who met the success inclusion criteria from the corporate (c-suite, president, vice president, director, or executive) or higher education sector (chancellor, president, vice president, dean, assistant dean, director, or department chair) participated in semi-structured interviews to explore what feminine attributes they credited to their success; how they used these attributes to lead effectively; and what must be offered for developing leadership in middle and high school girls. Findings revealed that successful women leaders integrate the feminine attributes of empathy, compassion, humility, advocacy, and nurturing with core leadership characteristics including authenticity, confidence, resilience, and courage to achieve effectiveness. A Relational Leadership Framework emerged comprised of communication, relationship cultivation, collaboration, and trust. Despite facing substantial systemic barriers throughout their careers, these women developed survival mechanisms through courage and professional boundary-setting. Study conclusions support feminine attributes function as leadership strengths not as detriments or limitations; relational leadership constitutes the core strategy for women’s overall effectiveness; women must develop personal and professional survival mechanisms to counter systemic barriers; and youth leadership development requires the emergent three-part female youth leadership framework combining exposure, experiential opportunities, and individualized mentoring.

Keywords

Developing leaders, Female youth leadership development, Femininity and leadership, Leadership, Women's leadership, Youth leadership

Library of Congress Subject Headings

Leadership in women; Women executives; Femininity; Leadership—Study and teaching; Girls—Leadership

Date of Award

2026

School Affiliation

Graduate School of Education and Psychology

Department/Program

Education

Degree Type

Dissertation

Degree Name

Doctorate

Faculty Advisor

Kay Davis

Subject Categories

Leadership Studies

Share

COinS