Abstract

Stages of ego development reflect increasingly more complex ways of making meaning from one’s experience. Ego development was considered a master personality trait in this study, which explored how ego development interacts with personality and influences leadership effectiveness for mid-level leaders. The data in this quantitative study included assessments results from 555 mid-level leaders within a large North American multinational organization who participated in transformational leadership development programs between 2018 and 2023. The measure of leadership effectiveness came from the Leadership Circle Profile, personality was measured with the Hogan personality assessments (HPI, HDS, MVPI), and the stage of ego development was assessed using the Global Leadership Profile (action logics). Later stages of ego development were found to contribute to leadership effectiveness however, only up to a point. Leaders at the post-conventional stage of Redefining were consistently rated lower on effectiveness by three stakeholder groups (manager, peers, direct reports), while leaders at the Achiever stage consistently received the highest ratings. The relationship between ego development and direct report ratings of the leader’s effectiveness was significantly nonlinear and personality influenced both ego development and leadership effectiveness. Five personality characteristics were significantly related to stages of ego development, both positively (Learning Approach and Aesthetics) and negatively (Adjustment, Security, and Hedonism). Personality’s influence on leadership effectiveness depended on both the stage of ego development and the stakeholder group rating them. Ego development significantly moderated the effect personality had on leadership effectiveness and showed how some characteristics changed from having a detrimental effect at one stage of development to having a beneficial one at another stage. Across the stakeholder groups there was limited agreement on leadership effectiveness ratings which suggests that the different stakeholder groups apply different criteria in their evaluation. Leadership effectiveness is both relationally and contextually complex, and effectiveness depends not just on the stage of development but on the interactions between a leader’s developmental stage, their personality characteristics, and the perspectives of those evaluating them in a specific context. The study has implications for leadership development practitioners who support post-conventional leaders in conventional organizational contexts.

Keywords

Action logics, Ego development, Leadership development, Mid-level leaders, Personality, Vertical development

Library of Congress Subject Headings

Leadership; Middle managers; Ego (Psychology); Personality

Date of Award

2026

School Affiliation

Graduate School of Education and Psychology

Department/Program

Education

Degree Type

Dissertation

Degree Name

Doctorate

Faculty Advisor

Seung Lee

Subject Categories

Leadership

Included in

Leadership Commons

Share

COinS