Abstract

This study examined how diversity conversations are initiated and sustained in clinical supervision and their impact on supervisees and the supervisory alliance. Using a hermeneutic-phenomenological approach, semi-structured interviews were conducted with six first-year doctoral practicum students in a clinical psychology program. Interviews were transcribed, analyzed, and interpreted with attention to both verbal and paralinguistic data. Findings revealed considerable variability in the frequency and depth of diversity conversations in supervision, ranging from absent or minimal discussion to more reflective, relational engagement. Two primary themes emerged: (a) a continuum of diversity discussions in supervision and (b) an association between the strength of the supervisory alliance and the depth of those conversations. Supervisors who demonstrated more curiosity and warmth were more likely to engage supervisees in meaningful discussions of culture and identity. In contrast, supervision focused on procedural or administrative tasks was associated with fewer diversity conversations. Drawing on mentalization, these findings suggest that the capacity to reflect on one’s own and others’ internal experiences may support frequent and deeper diversity conversations within the supervisory alliance.

Keywords

Clinical supervision, Diversity conversations, Mentalization, Phenomenology

Library of Congress Subject Headings

Clinical psychologists—Supervision of; Cultural competence; Psychologists—Training of; Interpersonal relations

Date of Award

2026

School Affiliation

Graduate School of Education and Psychology

Department/Program

Psychology

Degree Type

Dissertation

Degree Name

Doctorate

Faculty Advisor

Edward Shafranske

Subject Categories

Clinical Psychology

Share

COinS